Home / Reviews / Best Crib Mattress [2023 Updated]- Top 10 Rated Crib Mattresses Below

Best Crib Mattress [2023 Updated]- Top 10 Rated Crib Mattresses Below

Updated on June 21, 2022
Best Crib Mattress

The best crib mattress is essential for a great night of sleep and can start your day off in a good way or a bad way! This is true from adults to infants.

A baby is more likely to sleep better and longer on a mattress that is firm yet soft and cool.

A mattress that is too hard may make baby to uncomfortable to sleep, and a hot mattress could cause night time sweating!

Mattresses that sag or leave gaps between the crib bars and the actual mattress could leave your child at a higher risk for SIDS also known as Sudden Infant Death Syndrome.

A cotton mattress may be a better choice for those that don’t want to compromise on softness and don’t mind the clean up due to diapers leaks.

On the other hand if your a parent that would like to minimize how much time you spend cleaning the mattress and don’t mind the nose of the mattress cover then a non-cotton mattress is the way to go!

Make sure to get a mattress that fits your child’s needs whether they get hot easily or wake at every sound there’s a mattress out there for them.

Editor’s Choice

Sealy Soybean Foam Mattress

Sealy Soybeam Foam Mattress

Why is it better?

  • Lightweight
  • Memory foam
  • Easy to clean
  • Breathable

Check Latest Price

Read Review Details

The Lineup At A Glance

Top 10 Best Baby Crib Mattress Reviews

1. Sealy Soybean Foam Mattress- Memory Foam Mattress

Sealy Soybean Foam Mattress

If a mattress made from a renewable source found out in the elements is your fancy then this mattress is the mattress for your baby!

  • Easy to clean
  • Lightweight

  • Hot
  • May have ridges

Check Latest Price


Sealy has been manufacturing mattresses for over 130 years! Delicately creating products that make sleeping a pleasant idea and this line of baby mattresses is no exception to there brand.

In addition, soybean is one of the highest rated mattresses produced by Sealy. It’s no wonder this mattress was chosen as the top editors pick of the list! Tested by parents all over the world this mattress has received a stamp of approval.

The reinforced in memory foam core provides a quality that works dually for a comfortable rest and durability. Which is always a place when it comes to purchasing any mattress! The foam is also engineered to allow air flow in and out of it.

It comes with a pearl-embossed covering that makes cleaning it’s lightweight, waterproof surface much less of a hassle during those accidental diaper leaks or bottle spillings that may occur throughout the day.

The corners have been rounded in an effort to ensure that it will fit snugly within the parameters of your crib. GREENGUARD GOLD has given this mattress a certified stamp for making the indoors much healthier.

Lastly, this brand is ideal for children to toddlers 0-5 years of age and from newborn to a maximum of 60 pounds.

If you want to know more about foam play mat, we have an article for you.

2. Delta Children’s Twinkle Stars Mattress- Affordable Crib Mattress

Delta Children’s Twinkle Stars Mattress

Twinkle twinkle little star how I wonder how we got so lucky with this mattress choice! Babies dreams will be followed the billowing dreams every time.

  • Great price
  • Firm

  • Softness
  • Short

Check Latest Price


Delta Children was founded on the premises of making affordable high-quality and safe childrens furniture. All products are created with long-lasting capabilities in mind that can withstand years of jumping and playing!

The company creates a fiber core crib mattress as well as a mattress that fits in a toddler size bed. A thermo-bonded polyester ensures breathability and allows for the mattress to retain its shape no matter how long the baby uses the mattress.

In addition, with squared corners to fit snugly into the crib or toddler bed of your choice!

Allowing the mattress to remain in its tip-top condition is the waterproof cover that encases the mattress and makes cleaning up as easy as counting the sheep jumping over the moon! It offers essential support for any sleeping toddler or baby.

Lastly, this lightweight mattress surpasses the testing done on flammability and toxicity retardants. In case anything goes wrong with the mattress Delta Children want to make it right offering every customer a 7 year warranty on their products!

3. Moonlight Slumber Dreamer Mattress- Best crib mattress for baby

Moonlight Slumber Dreamer Mattress

Starlight star bright will my baby have awesome dreams tonight ? With this mattress the only thing that will be awake tonight is the moon and all of the stars!

  • Durable
  • Quality
  • Defective
  • Too short

Check Latest Price


While this line is made to be more economical than other mattresses it is still amongst some of the safest in its class. It comes complete with dual sided sleeping surface to allow for maximum comfort while your baby rests.

The plant infused oil side is for infant use and the firmer side is for use by your toddler.

Yes you read that correctly plant infused oil! Have you ever considered using essential oils to help baby get a more restful night of sleep?

Well look no more this smartly engineered mattress contains plant oil just inside the foam of the inner mattress! And is wrapped in a woven fabric that is water, odor, and stain resistant without the harsh chemicals.

In addition, the Safe sewn seams stand strong against bed bugs and dust mites that may try to infiltrate the mattress without success. The mattress goes through a strenuous number of tests to make sure your baby remains safe and sound.

Tests such as performance-testing procedures, durability evaluation, safety, and basic performance as in is it comfortable or not. And is also 100% manufactured in the United States and imported.

4. Dream On Me Mattress- Standard crib mattress

Dream On Me Mattress

If you want your baby to have the sweetest dreams on earth then this mattress is the only choice for you and your family!

  • Water resistant
  • Soft
  • Split seams
  • Noisy

Check Latest Price


Extra firmness is essential with this portable crib mattress. When considering this mattress keep in mind that the only two things or their minds are safety and comfort for your baby.

It also includes a waterproof cover that keeps the mattress from mold, mildew, and odor or stains. The product feels great knowing that even with the cover the mattress doesn’t sacrifice the quality with the high density foam core!

In addition, it has been checked off in compliance with the Federal Flammability Standard 16 CFR 1633. However, the makers of the mattress do not recommend using this mattress with the Playard.

Breathability and a clean airflow are at the top of the list for the features this mattress has to offer. A clear airflow allows baby’s breathing to remain unobstructed and easy during the duration of their sleep cycle.

If you should have any issues with this mattress or any other product from this manufacturer they offer all of their customers a 30-day warranty.So it is easy to exchange in the event that the mattress has any unforeseeable issues.

5. Big Oshi Waterproof Mattress- Waterproof mattress

Big Oshi Waterproof Mattress

The square mattress not really fitting your particular design preference or crib! Luckily this oval mattress came to the market!

  • Easy to essemble
  • Value
  • Not fat
  • Leaves gaps

Check Latest Price


Need a mattress that can fit safely within a bassinet or a crib ? Then look no further than the Oshi brand with its unique oval design makes it optimal in other crib choice!

The quilted rose pattern is made 100% of a waterproof vinyl material. Although the material may cause baby to get slightly warmer than other mattresses it makes cleaning leaks easier!

If your child is a light sleep no need to worry this mattress comes with the crinkle material that may startle the baby during nap time. All mattresses are 2” thick!

Hence, made from a soft urethane foam filler. Along with the waterproof material to make cleaning it easier this mattress can be washed in your washing machine!

Lastly, it fits a standard sized small toddler bed, standard sized bassinets, and standard sized crib mattresses. The design is just as important as the cost if oval is your thing choose right with Oshi!

6. My First Crib Mattress-Baby bed mattress

My First Crib Mattress

Babies first year of life will be full of many first time events! Make this mattress a central part of the many firsts that are to come!

  • Soft
  • Comfortable
  • Doesn’t maintain shape
  • Hard

Check Latest Price


My first crib is a mattress made by a company called Kittrich. This company manufactures not only baby products, but everyday used household items as well! They seek to use the most natural supplies to create a natural product.

This company is unique in that their website features a tab where customers can choose from a list of expos where they can come and see the products in person prior to making their final purchasing decisions. Now that is sure to breed customer satisfaction!

In addition, the crib is made with ozone depletors and without harsh chemicals and other flame retardants! There is no use of mercury, lead, other heavy metals, formaldehyde, phthalates. Paired with low emissions to increase the air quality indoors.

The mattress has been created with extra thickness because if a mattress is too soft it can create a suffocation hazard for a sleeping baby. And the last thing we want to do is make sleeping something scary for baby to look forward too!

My first crib mattress exceeds the state law size requirement of at least 27 ¼ inches by 51 ⅝ inches with a mattress that measures 51 ⅝ inches by 27 1/4X5 inches ! CertiPur-US certified foam!

7. Simmons Slumbertime Mattress-Baby bed mattress

Simmons Slumbertime Mattress

Slumbertime is the right time for a great night or afternoon of rest. Whenever, wherever your baby can surely have a restful slumber on this mattress!

  • Holds shape
  • Waterproof
  • Smeel weird
  • Too firm

Check Latest Price


Beautyrest manufacturers have been helping customers achieve a restful night of sleep since 1990. They have three categories of mattresses with Beautyrest platinum, Beautyrest black, and Beautyrest silver.

The simmons signature coil machine process was born and then the categories were formed after this process became perfected in 1925.

Whichever mattress you choose if your baby loves it enough there’s a duplicate mattress that can be found in the same size for adults. We call that a score!

In the 1950s Simmons products became the first to introduce the king and queen mattress sets with a hybrid technology being engineered in 2008 giving the rest of the industry a much needed kick in the stuffing to catch up with their ingenuity.

The mattress is made with a 2-in-1 design that will grow with your child as well as distinct infant and toddler siding. The soy-enhance foam gives the mattress an extra comfortable cushion-like quality .

It keeps baby comfortable and dry which also allows for the continued longevity of the mattress and other common Simmons products.

8. LA Baby Waterproof Mattress- Best infant mattress

LA Baby Waterproof Mattress

From LA to wherever your home is located this mattress is a world traveler taking in all the needed features that make a mattress a great mattress!

  • Comfort
  • Easy to clean
  • Flimsy
  • Small

Check Latest Price


The LA mattress comes in a white, triple laminated, tear resistant, box edged constructed material. Making the outer layer of the mattress waterproof. If it seems to you like every mattress on the market is waterproof for easy cleanup this mattress goes a step further!

Anti-microbial engineering maintains that this mattress is phthalate free, non-toxic, non-allergenic, and stain resistant. All it takes to clean this mattress is mild soap and warm water.

The size of the mattress 24 “x 38” x 3” and is measured at just over 3” of thickness! Smartly crafted to fit within most portable crib sets.

The downfall to this particular mattress is unlike other manufacturers this mattress only provides a one year warranty package to customers!

The outer layer is made of a jersey like material that gives the effect of laying on a t-shirt. Available in a variety of colors and fun patterns to match any paint color or theme of the baby room.

You can use the mattress with washer and drier.

9. American Baby Company Mattress- Memory foam mattress

American Baby Company Mattress Pad

An all american baby deserves an all american mattress pad. Serving the red, white, and blue one restful night of sleep at a time!

  • Comfortable
  • Lightweigh
  • Quality
  • Durability

Check Latest Price


The motto of the American Baby Company is to provide care and comfort for the next generation. It is a company based out of California and was founded in 1997. These products are designed and sold only in North America.

Their line of bedding products placed a huge amount of emphasis on quality, comfort, safety, and value

Their line fits within any nursery setting and the print collection has every print to fit whichever trend you find yourself obsessing over!

This mattress pad features a 9” pocket for a snug and safe fit .It’s like a mattress with a built in swaddle capability lessening the likelihood of baby getting tangled in any loose blankets that might be left in the crib.

Lastly, the knitted and woven cotton styled come at a very reasonable price and it is worth it with the quality that this mattress is created with. This mattress pad comes in 3 sizes and 4 different styles.

10. Lullaby Earth Breeze Mattress- Baby bed mattress

Lullaby Earth Breeze Mattress

Rockabye baby on the tree top when the wind settles this cradle will rock and down will come baby safely and cushion on a Lullaby Earth Mattress!

  • Soft
  • Breathable
  • Cost friendly
  • Sags

Check Latest Price


They design the lullaby with physical, chemical, allergenic, hygienic, and enhanced breathability benefits as witnessed on the companies website!

It was created by parents, grandparents, and engineers whom all had child safety at the forefront of their minds!

With a patented WaveSport core it meets and exceeds the FDA’s food contact standards! This mattress is known for its durability lasting well beyond toddler years making it a great addition to a growing family.

You will not find a single soybean anywhere in this product as it is 100% polyurethane free! It features a built in protective pad that is breathable as well as waterproof protecting the inside core from liquids and dirt.

Unlike most other mattresses this company allows customers the opportunity to have a lifetime warranty!

Lastly, meaning no matter which child is now using it 5 years down the road you can always contact the company and they will promptly address all of your mattress concerns.

How to choose the Best Baby Crib Mattress

When choosing a babies mattress all of the SIDS warning signs start flashing at the forefront of every parents mind .

But, if you keep a few criteria at the top of your list they are sure to decrease you worry about your child’s safety while their resting.

A mattress that maintains its shape, size, and firmness insure that your child is comfortable as they enter into a nap or night of sleep!

Durability and quality go hand in hand because a quality mattress will last for as long as the baby needs it to last whether that means until they outgrow it or transition to a toddler bed.

An easy to clean mattress makes late night changes less stressful for everyone involved and ultimately the price of the mattress may dictate which one you end up choosing!

1. Maintains Shape

The mattress doesn’t sag or lose its shape over time creating a SIDS risk for the child . When a mattress sags or loses its shape not only does it put the baby at risk, but it also will cause your child’s body to not feel as supported as it could be. And as any parent knows when your child isn’t placed in a comfortable sleeping position they may wiggle and grunt until the optimal sleeping position is achieved. A supportive mattress that keeps its shape can also cause less bunching of sheets that may not fit adequately on a mattress that tends to sag.

2. Price

Baby mattresses cost on average between $90-$200. When choosing a mattress determine how much you are willing to spend on mattress. Then consider growth potential is a mattress that can’t transition and be used with a toddler bed worth the purchase or is a mattress meant specifically for an infant crib the best choice due to wanting to purchase a larger bed when your little one is ready to make the leap from crib to bed.

3. Durability

The mattress that lasts a long period of time could be a mattress that is used for a family that intends to have more children that way you’re not purchasing a new mattress every time your family is expecting a new addition. Durability is important because the length of time a baby spends sleeping in a crib is different for each child and it is important to have a mattress that can be used until the baby no longer needs to use the mattress.

4. Size

It is the proper size for the crib leaving no gaps between the bars and the mattress reducing SIDS related deaths . The wrong size mattress can lead to gaps and pose a suffocation risk for your child. Before purchasing your mattress measure the dimensions of the crib you have purchased to make sure that the mattress you have ordered will fit properly within the parameters set by your crib manufacturer.

5. Easy To Clean

In the case of a diaper leakage or a sweaty night the mattress is able to be wiped clean easily . Especially during the summer months a baby that tends to get hot easily may sweat more than a child whom does not get hot easily. Also sometimes a full diaper can cause a leak and it may be easier to simply remove the flat sheet and wipe the surface off versus having to deep clean a cotton mattress to make sure no stains or smells linger after the leak has been cleaned up.

6. Firmness

Mattress isn’t too soft or too hard but is just right and provides babies body the support it needs for a restful night of sleep . Just like adults babies have a preference as to what mattress is the best fit for them. A baby will let you know when they are uncomfortable so pay attention to your child’s cues when they begin sleeping on the mattress. If they are constantly moving and making noises and softer or firmer mattress may be a better choice.

7. Quality

Is the mattress made out of material that is worth the price you as the parent are paying for the mattress . Is the material breathable and doesn’t serve as an incubator of body temperature that may cause baby to sweat at night. Does it keep your child cool without any ridges or easily noticeable open seams along the mattress.

Frequently Asked Questions

Does this mattress create any gaps between the crib and the mattress ?

No this crib doesn’t leave gaps our engineers have worked hard to create a product that helps to give parents peace of mind when in use.

Are all mattresses waterproof ?

No cotton mattresses will be much more prone to absorbing any liquid that is leaked on it and will need to be washed more than waterproof protectant mattresses.

Will this mattress maintain its shape ?

Yes this mattress is a firm mattress and is so durable that it is able to transition from infant to toddler use.

Is this mattress worth the price ?

Inevitable that decision is up to you as the parent sometimes in the name of quality you will have to pay extra and sometimes quality doesn’t mean a higher price.

Is the mattress heavy ?

Our mattress is made of a lightweight breathable material making it soft and easy to handle.

Leave a Comment