Consumer Reports Issues Warning For Valco Baby Tri-Mode, Tike Tech City X3 & Tike Tech X3 Sport Strollers

Consumer Reports named three stroller models on their “Don’t Buy: Safety Risk” list yesterday (April 15). After recent tests,they found the Valco Baby Tri-Mode, Tike Tech City X3 all-terrain strollers and the Tike Tech X3 Sport jogging stroller to pose a danger to children.

All three models have a grab bar at the front of the seating area. There are gaps big enough to allow an unharnessed child’s torso but not the child’s head to pass, or “submarine,” under the grab bar. The child’s head could become stuck, causing serious injury or death. Consumer Reports recommends that children always be harnessed in strollers, high chairs, and car seats to prevent injury.

The current voluntary stroller standard of the American Society for Testing and Materials requires that if a space beneath a stroller’s tray/grab bar can permit a small child’s torso to pass through, it must also be big enough to allow the child’s head to pass through. Those three strollers failed our test of that standard, and results were confirmed by an outside lab. If you have any of the strollers, we recommend that you remove and discard the grab bar. (See our latest all-terrain stroller Ratings and recommendations.)

We contacted the manufacturers about our findings. Valco Baby’s national sales manager, Shalom New, said that the stroller we tested was an older model and that the newer Tri-Mode EX has a grab bar with only two positions (fully up or fully down). When we performed our test of the ASTM standard on an EX that we purchased, it also failed. Tike Tech’s president, David Ambar, predicted that an “improved version” of its strollers would pass the standard. We will test those strollers when they’re available.

Both manufacturers told Consumer Reports that no reports on children being injured by the grab bars of the strollers had been filed or reported. From 1995 to 2008, the Consumer Product Safety Commission reported 10 infant deaths associated with submarining, though they don’t identify the strollers involved.

A mom to two girls and a baby boy, a writer and the publisher of Child Mode. As a lover of style and fashion, Nadia found her ‘niche’ and love of children’s clothing while searching for quality items for her family.


Share this post!

4 Responses to "Consumer Reports Issues Warning For Valco Baby Tri-Mode, Tike Tech City X3 & Tike Tech X3 Sport Strollers"

Add Comment
  1. Pingback: Tweets that mention Consumer Reports Issues Warning For Valco Baby Tri-Mode, Tike Tech City X3 & Tike Tech X3 Sport Strollers - Child Mode -- Topsy.com

  2. Standard Strollers

    April 18, 2010 at 12:43 am

    The Tike Tech Trax 360 is an extremely light and easy to push swivel wheeled stroller, priced far below many other swivel wheel jogging strollers. Standard Strollers

  3. Pingback: Jogging Strollers Recalled By Valco Baby Due to Strangulation Hazard - Child Mode

  4. Dennis Black

    November 3, 2010 at 5:35 pm

    I have one of these strollers and the thing is just falling apart. Plus the 5 point harness was to small and they gave us some stupid extenders, only one side of brakes are working, most of the snap buttons have broken due to rust, the fabric harness belt that holds the seat up and lets it down is almost worn out. Also the rain cover wore out right away and they gave us another and it fell apart in less than 6 months. we still have it but it is full of holes. I don’t see any reason to purchase another.

    I did like the stroller initially, but I would not recommend my model to anyone.
    As for price it is cheaper than the others, but maybe that is due to cheaper components installed.

Submit a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>